sbwpix:  sbw
Just add Waters - Stephen Waters' casual blog

Home

About

Contents

Guidelines

Glossary

Contacts


Discussion

Recent Discussion

Create New Topic


Membership

Join Now

Login

Measured steps toward civilization

     [Note: First Draft Summary]

This is important -- more important than one might recognize.

Think back to a time in your life when you thought you were right but were not -- only later to painfully discover that the mental map by which you make your decisions wasn't as accurate as it needed to be. The lesson to be abstracted from experience: If you think you are right when you are not, how are you going to know?

Reflection on personal experience like this leads to humility -- an understanding that, while not a natural, immutable law, can be equally accessible across cultural boundaries to different societies, to others who come to similar conclusions based on lessons from their own personal experience.

That lesson scales up, like concentric circles, from individuals, to groups, to societies. Individuals band together into societies to gain advantage they otherwise would not have. A society's experience shows that it, too, can be mistaken. It, too, can think it is correct when it is not. Successful societies develop humility for the same reason individuals do.

fabric0602Thumb:

Warp and weft of society

Humility is like the warp threads of a carpet -- lending stability, strength and durability -- holding together the pile knots of a carpet that represent the individuals in a society -- each possibly of different color, texture, material, or length. Continuing the carpet analogy, the weft threads represent reciprocity -- the consideration that others live their lives as acutely as you do and earn respect accordingly if they reciprocate. Without what the warp and weft provide, there is only a clump of threads.

Humility and reciprocity are the common threads that draw individuals into a society and are the test not only of whether society exists, but also of whether there is hope for civilization.

The race for civilization

We are in a race for civilization there is no guarantee we will win and no particular interest that we do win on the part of Mother Nature. If we win, it will be because we value civilization enough to make it happen -- if we understand why to value it. That's not something regularly taught because until now it didn't have to be.

Until this generation, natural buffers of geography and technology (travel and communication) and limits for projecting power have insulated societies enough from rogue individuals and cultures. No more. It is dangerous to be ignorant about what binds societies together and why in an age, as Jacob Bronowski advised, when science has put sufficient power in the hands of anyone who cares to learn, that an iron box will no longer protect your valuables nor an iron door protect your family.

The race is to convince those outside a protective umbrella manufactured with humility, reciprocity, and resulting process of peaceful process resolution, that their long term best interests rest underneath the umbrella -- and that the alternative is that those under the umbrella have the courage and the resolve to defend themselves.

Getting beyond what hasn't worked ...

For the first time in history, finding solid foundations for inter-relating societies has gone beyond important to become essential. We are in a race to uncover threads that can pull societies together and learn how to present those ideas accessibly and in a compelling fashion. Several thousand years of experience shows what hasn't worked, but changes in language and thought, along with new metaphors make it easier to present in a compelling way what just might work. Before now, there have been several dead ends.
  • Trying to deduce platonic universal principles foundered on the rocks of arguments constructed by later philosophical relativists.
  • Pure intellectual efforts, like those of Descartes or Kant, weren't sufficient, because they were unable to bridge the gap between cultures.
  • Religions are limited to convinced believers.
  • Trying to factor actual societies back to first principles failed because many societies were formed for Machiavellian reasons of pure power. Nor does relativism allow any communication or judgment except the exercise of power. Such factors described what was done. They did not explain what should be done and why.
Civilization, in this sense, is the unification of disparate independent societies under a uniformly acceptable protective umbrella for the benefit of the individuals that make up each society. The problem is to develop sufficient shared experience between participants in distinctly different cultures, that a mutually acceptable framework can be agreed upon that will allow shared goals and peaceful problem resolution amongst members.

... To the substance of what will work

Democracy is a process of peaceful problem resolution that codifies humility -- the possibility that there may be a better way and that, for society's sake, any individual deserves the opportunity to convince others of it, not just now, but regularly in the future. A society that does not allow peaceful problem resolution not only plants the seeds of its own destruction, it is a danger to other societies. Other societies need to be prepared to defend themselves from those who do not believe in institutional processes that allow peaceful change.

Making decisions; measuring behavior

For individuals, societies, and civilization the twin threads of humility and consideration of others measure what is important and explain why. They form the cornerstones of the processes by which ethical decisions are made. No matter the cultural background of the society, applicable virtues can be deduced from them. And, interestingly, the untenable facets of their own societies are exposed.

Discuss

[Macro error: Can't find a sub-table named "commentIt".]

This page was last updated: Sunday, March 5, 2006 at 3:52:49 PM
Copyright 2008 Stephen B. Waters Weblog at: http://blogs.rny.com/sbw/
Create your own Manila site in minutes. Everyone's doing it!

This site is using the Default theme.